Saturday, February 1, 2014

Ebook vs. Book Book

    My Dad asked me the other day, “Why did you have to go to the library?  Why aren’t you just reading on your new iPad?”  This made me think of the new literacies of today.  While I do read ebooks downloaded from the library website for 10 days at a time and they are very accessible when reading during transition times, I also enjoy a paper copy of a book once in a while.  When will this trend change?  Will the next generations be strictly ebook readers, placing virtual bookmarks, and sliding a finger or tapping a screen to “flip” backwards to reread?  Do we gain more knowledge or pleasure from reading an ebook?

    While reading Carla Neggers “Declan’s Cross” an FBI thriller with a little romance thrown in, I thought about how I sometimes read too fast to comprehend.  Just so you know, it is a hard copy version, found while browsing through the shelves of the library instead of a computer screen. I have been pleasure reading right before bed because it gives my mind something to think about other than the stress of life.  I’ve noticed that I go in and out of engagement with the book.  One minute I am reading along and connecting it with my prior knowledge of the story and the next I am thinking about what is going on in my life while still reading the words.  I have to stop and track backwards to find where I stopped paying attention to the meaning.  Meanwhile the book is falling out of my hands or I have to switch positions to see the left page or the right page.  I wonder if this is how a struggling reader reads when they know the words but cannot retell the story because they don’t know the strategy of going back and rereading? 


     My question is, is it harder or easier to focus on the meaning of the text when you are reading before bed or in the afternoon? Is it harder or easier to focus on the meaning of the text when reading an ebook or paper text?  Is it harder or easier to focus on the meaning of the text when you have to stop and look backwards?  

No comments:

Post a Comment